The $28,303 Question: Is Self-Funding Still Out of Reach for Small Employers?
For many CFOs and HR leaders, self-funding still sounds like a strategy reserved for companies with thousands of employees. But company size alone doesn’t determine whether a self-funded health plan can work. The real test is whether your organization can manage claims variability, cash flow, stop-loss protection, and plan administration with the right partners in place.
The stakes are significant. The 2026 KFF Employer Health Benefits Survey reports that average annual family coverage premiums reached $28,303, up 5% from 2025. Workers’ average contribution rose 9% to $7,471. For employers seeking affordable employee benefits and a competitive benefits package for employees, another renewal increase is not a strategy.
The question is not simply “Are we big enough?” It is “Do we have the information, financing, and support to choose the right funding model?”
The real test is readiness, not headcount
Self-funded health plans let an employer fund employee claims as they occur, rather than paying a fixed premium that transfers claim risk to an insurer. Employers typically work with a third-party administrator (TPA) to administer the plan and purchase stop loss insurance to protect against claims above agreed thresholds.
That structure offers more control, but it calls for thoughtful planning. Before considering self-funded insurance, assess four practical factors:
Claims predictability: How stable is your workforce, and what do you know about its claims patterns? Small groups can be more affected by a single high-cost claimant, making reliable data and careful plan design essential.
Cash flow and claims financing: Can your business manage claims payments as they arise, including timing differences between paying claims and receiving stop-loss reimbursements? Financing arrangements may help smooth cash flow, but their terms and costs matter.
Stop-loss terms: What are the specific and aggregate attachment points, exclusions, contract basis, and reimbursement rules? The lowest premium is not necessarily the strongest protection.
Administrative capacity: Do you have a partner to handle claims administration, employee support, compliance coordination, reporting, and plan oversight? Self-funding does not mean HR has to do all of that alone.
Large claims make the risk conversation especially important. Oliver Wyman reports that the frequency of medical stop-loss claims exceeding $2 million rose 150% between 2020 and 2024. Meanwhile, Segal’s 2027 Health Plan Cost Trend Survey projects a pharmacy cost trend of about 11.5% for 2027. These figures make a strong case for active plan oversight, not for assuming every small employer should take on risk without safeguards.

Level funding offers a practical on-ramp
For employers who want more visibility without moving immediately to a traditional self-funded arrangement, level-funded health plans can be a middle step. A level-funded plan typically combines a set monthly payment with estimated claims funding, administrative costs, and stop-loss coverage. The exact structure and terms vary by plan.
This arrangement can make budgeting simpler while giving an employer a chance to learn how its plan performs. Depending on the contract, lower-than-expected claims may result in a surplus refund or credit. But that outcome is not guaranteed, and a refund should never be treated as assured savings.
Level funded plan pros and cons, without the gloss
Potential advantages: Monthly payments can make budgeting more predictable. Stop-loss protection can limit exposure for covered claims above the contract’s thresholds. Employers may have an opportunity to benefit when claims are lower than projected. A level-funded plan can also give a company experience with claims-based funding before moving to a more customized self-funded health plan.
Important trade-offs: Predictable payments do not eliminate underlying claim risk. Stop-loss coverage has specific terms, and reimbursement may not happen at the same time a claim is paid. Some level-funded arrangements provide limited claims detail, restrict access to underlying data, or make it difficult to understand how renewal pricing was set. If your data access is restricted, it can be harder to evaluate the plan or negotiate the next renewal.
Renewal conditions also deserve scrutiny. Mercer’s reporting on Marsh placements found an average stop-loss renewal increase near 23% for the January 2026 cycle. Separately, the Aegis Risk Medical Stop-Loss Premium Survey reported negotiated increases of roughly 13.6% to 15.9%, varying by deductible. These figures come from different datasets and should not be treated as directly comparable quotes or forecasts for your company. They do underline why employers should ask how stop-loss pricing, renewal protections, and plan data will work before signing.

Ask your prospective TPA to show its work
A TPA health plan is not automatically a narrow-network or bare-bones plan. A TPA administers a plan; the provider network and benefit design depend on the arrangement selected. Employers can seek competitive national provider network access, including access to Cigna and Aetna networks where available through the chosen plan. Confirm the actual network, geographic fit, and participation terms rather than relying on a logo or a general claim.
TPA flexibility should also mean more than a long menu of options. Ask how the partner will help shape a plan around your workforce, your budget, and your priorities.
Before selecting a TPA, ask:
What claims data will we receive, how often, and in what level of detail? Ask whether you’ll have 100% access to your plan data, including usable reporting and clear data ownership terms.
How does your large claim management process work? Ask who identifies emerging high-cost claims, coordinates support, and monitors stop-loss reimbursements.
Which provider networks can our employees use? Request network details for employees’ locations, including available national options such as Cigna or Aetna.
How much can we customize the plan? Ask about benefit design, cost-sharing, network selection, and access to cost-containment solutions.
How are renewals explained? Request a clear breakdown of claims, stop-loss costs, administrative fees, and assumptions behind proposed changes.
What support will employees receive? HR needs a partner that can answer questions and help employees navigate care, not simply process paperwork.
At Quilt Benefits, we partner with employers to build flexible plans with Smart Fabric Networks, claims insight, and a Full Stack Platform. Our approach emphasizes 100% access to plan data, large claim management, TPA flexibility, and custom plan design. Quilt-reported results include 48% savings on large claimants and potential savings of up to 30%; results vary by employer and plan. Learn more about our solutions.

Self-funded vs. fully insured: choose for your company
In a self-funded vs. fully insured decision, there is no universal winner. Fully insured coverage may suit employers that prioritize transferring claims risk and prefer a familiar fixed premium structure. Self-funded plans can suit employers ready for greater control, deeper plan insight, and the opportunity to shape benefits around their employees, with stop-loss protection and experienced administration in place.
Level funding can be a useful stepping stone, especially when a company wants more predictable monthly payments while evaluating a different funding approach. But weigh its limitations carefully: ask how much claims data you will actually see, how renewals are determined, and whether the arrangement leaves your organization with enough control to make informed decisions.
For CFOs, the goal is a funding strategy that supports financial confidence. For HR, it is a manageable program with a responsive partner. For employees, it is a benefits package that offers meaningful coverage and access to care. Benefits don’t have to be confusing, and a company does not have to be enormous to make a well-supported funding decision.
Find out what your plan could save
Whether you’re reviewing health insurance for small business, comparing level-funded health plans, or assessing a move to self-funding, start with your own plan’s numbers. Use the Quilt Benefits Savings Calculator to explore potential savings and start a conversation about the right approach for your organization.
